In this conversation, my friend Stephen Prouse (The Fourth Watch) and I take on a couple of the most contentious issues in American church culture, and talk honestly about discernment, motives, church culture, influence, power, and what it means to pursue truth without losing our love for Christ or one another.
Jeremy Slayden’s personal thoughts:
Every day, I hear from (mostly older) Christians who share a similar concern: they feel trapped between a loss of trust for institutional Christian leaders and a healthy skepticism toward independent voices that might lack accountability or a consistent standard of truth. Think TPUSA 2.0 vs Candace Owens…or Mike Huckabee vs Tucker Carlson.
This dynamic is clearly visible in the evangelical world, and it is eerily similar to what happened during the Covid era. Remember when the medical institutions—from the CDC to rural hospitals—locked arms with Big Pharma, Big Media, and Big Government to promote a narrative and a set of protocols that demanded near-universal compliance, with zero tolerance for questions? The result was a profound collapse of public trust in those institutions, which remains to this day. As confidence in the old players eroded, many people turned elsewhere. Podcasters and independent media became the tip of the spear, exposing falsehoods, challenging official claims, and creating new spaces where alternative explanations were explored. Yet that migration came with its own hazards. Alongside courageous truth-seekers emerged opportunists, cranks, and conspiracy-soaked voices willing to believe almost anything—as long as it contradicted the official narrative.
Similarly in the American Church, leadership voices we once respected appear to be unequivocally accepting official government narratives, many of which strike the general public as false —like the current FBI narrative on the murder of Charlie Kirk. So instead of “trust the science”, its either “trust Trump” or “trust the Bible” while refusing to honestly wrestle with well known facts that could challenge their current narratives, or even their theological positions.
At the same time, other voices seem eager to expose deception everywhere, but might also appear to chase conspiracies behind every rock, with little accountability or commitment to a consistent standard of truth.
Perhaps most frustrating of all, neither side seems willing to simply say, “We got this wrong.”
As a result, many believers feel disoriented, distrustful, and increasingly isolated—longing for voices that are both courageous enough to pursue truth and humble enough to admit when they miss it.
In this conversation, my friend Stephen Prouse (The Fourth Watch) and I talk honestly about discernment, motives, church culture, influence, power, and what it means to pursue truth without losing our love for Christ or one another.
Neither of us claims to have all the answers. In fact, one of the most important lessons we’ve learned is that discernment isn’t simply finding “our side.” It’s learning how to hear the Lord in a noisy world and refusing to surrender the courage of our convictions to personalities, institutions, or narratives.
If this conversation encourages you, please share it with others. Your shares, comments, and likes help these discussions reach people who are searching for clarity.
And if my work has blessed you, please consider becoming a paid subscriber. Paid subscriptions make these long-form conversations, deep dives, and research projects possible, and they allow me to continue producing material that I simply can’t create anywhere else.
Thank you for reading, listening, and supporting JSlayUSA. I’m grateful for each of you. Thank you Ken Roman, Jonah -I- Dissident, Felecia Maxwell, Rose Wambold, and many others for tuning into my live video! Join me for my next live video in the app.
